- Advertisement -
Top StoriesDriver sues Huron Co. homeowner after fortified mailbox causes...

Driver sues Huron Co. homeowner after fortified mailbox causes truck to flip; OH Supreme Court reviewing


- Advertisment -

BELLEVUE — Justices with the Ohio Supreme Court heard oral arguments Wednesday over a mailbox post dispute between a homeowner and a crash victim.

In December 2016, Cletus Snay crashed his pickup truck into Matthew Burr’s mailbox on Young Road in Bellevue after hitting a patch of black ice.

“He slides on black ice and collides with the mailbox post, which, contrary with postal service guidelines, doesn’t break away,” attorney Kathleen St. John explained. “Initiating the rollover sequence which results in Mr. Snay’s quadriplegia.”

What makes this case out of the ordinary is that Burr had installed a mailbox post made out of an eight-inch metal pole, buried three feet in the ground with rocks and dry cement poured on top.

“The hazardous object in this case is a severely reinforced mailbox post,” St. John added, arguing that previous cases point to the fortified mailbox post as a dangerous object. “An owner of property is not justified in inflicting, without warning, bodily harm upon the person of a trespasser or petty pilferer by means of traps, spring guns or instrumentalities of destruction unless he would have been justified in using that force if he had been personally present.”

The issue at hand for the court to decide is whether or not the homeowner is liable for the crash given that the driver alleges his pickup truck would not have flipped over had it not been for the fortified mailbox post.

As to why the mailbox post was first put in place, court paperwork details the damage done to this mailbox over the years, including trailers and snow plows clipping it, a pumpkin thrown at it, and vandals knocking it over several times.

“Are you telling me a homeowner cannot reinforce their mailbox if they are the victim of repeated vandalism?” Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor asked.

“Yes I am, that’s what I’m saying,” attorney St. John responded.

Guidelines from the Federal Highway Administration, that posted are on the US Postal Service website, highlight how Burr’s mailbox post was too deep in the ground and made of the wrong material, but was not illegal.

“Guidelines do not set forth duty of care, they are just guidelines,” said attorney Doug Leak, who is representing Burr. “The public has an absolute right to travel on the roadways in a usual and ordinary manner. The moment a motorist veers off that course, that same protection does not extend off the roadway.”

USPS Guidelines


Guidelines posted on the USPS website for how to install a mailbox

A ruling by the Ohio Supreme Court is expected in the near future.

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Opinion | Do Mask Mandates Work?

For example, Florida, which last week accounted for more than 20 percent of Covid-19 cases reported in the...

Activision, Facing Internal Turmoil, Grapples With #MeToo Reckoning

More than 1,500 workers for the video game maker Activision Blizzard walked out from their jobs this week....

Graham Company Announces Season of In-Person Performances

The Martha Graham Dance Company will debut new works by Andrea Miller and Hofesh Shechter in New York...

‘Stillwater’ review: Matt Damon stars as a dad crusading to free his daughter

The story owes an obvious debt to the Amanda Knox case, with Abigail Breslin playing Allison, an American...

Must read

Opinion | Do Mask Mandates Work?

For example, Florida, which last week accounted for...

Activision, Facing Internal Turmoil, Grapples With #MeToo Reckoning

More than 1,500 workers for the video game...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you